Covers are a mixed bag. Sometimes you get a carbon copy. It’s okay, but the artist didn’t really add anything to
it. On the other end of the
spectrum you get the “poetic license” cover where the artist really stretches
the limit of the song, and really makes the song their own. In this case I’m not really sure which
is the case.
Kurt
Cobain mentioned this song several times during his life saying that it really
touched him and made him cry.
Personally, I don’t blame him.
The subject is pretty heavy.
If you listen to the lyrics it’s about a guy saying his final goodbyes
to the world. The version he would
have listened to is the 1974 Terry Jack version, if I’m not mistaken, but he
could have also heard a version by the Television Personalities. This song has been covered so many
times that he could have taken bits from quite a few different versions.
If
he based this song off the Jack version then he falls in the middle of the two extremes. This version is certainly unique with
own with his inclusion of certain lyrics, and a few new lyrics (because he
forgot them). At the same time he certainly
doesn’t stray to far from the version that inspired him.
Give
it a listen, and keep in mind this was an impromptu recording that wasn’t
intended for release. It
adds a level of sincerity and spontaneity that Nirvana was really known for.
No comments:
Post a Comment